Little late to the thread I know, but I had to post.
Chris Reeve is definately the best Superman, but I also like Tom Welling.
Even though I really liked Superman Returns and thought Brandon was good, I still would've liked to see Tom actually play Superman & not just Clark. I was kinda pissed they didn't wait for Smallville to end before doing more movies.
Unlike Routh, Welling can actually act mad.
But hey, what are ya gonna do?
-Rogue21